Juventus are firmly in the Serie A title race this season, but not everyone is convinced that their resurgence is due to their own brilliance. A well-known pundit has sparked controversy by claiming that the Bianconeri’s progress is largely a result of the declining quality of Serie A rather than their own improvement.
After a difficult 2022–23 campaign marred by financial troubles and a 10-point deduction, Juventus have bounced back in 2024. Massimiliano Allegri’s men have been grinding out results, staying within touching distance of league leaders Inter Milan. Their defensive solidity and ability to win tight matches have been key to their rise in the standings.
However, one outspoken pundit believes Juventus’ position is misleading. According to him, the real reason for their success isn’t their own tactical brilliance but rather the declining competitiveness of Serie A as a whole.
For years, Serie A has struggled to maintain its reputation as one of Europe’s elite leagues. While Italian teams performed well in European competitions last season, some argue that the domestic league is weaker than ever. Several top teams, including AC Milan, Roma, and Napoli, have been inconsistent this season, failing to provide a strong title challenge.
Moreover, the league has seen a talent drain, with several high-profile departures to the Saudi Pro League and the Premier League. This has led some to question whether Juventus’ progress is truly a sign of their return to dominance or simply a reflection of a weakened competition.
Despite these claims, Juventus supporters argue that their team deserves credit for their improvement. Allegri has built a team that is difficult to beat, relying on defensive discipline and clinical finishing. Players like Federico Chiesa and Dusan Vlahovic have stepped up, while youngsters like Kenan Yildiz have added excitement to the squad.
Furthermore, Juventus have maintained their position near the top without the distractions of European football. This has allowed Allegri to focus solely on the domestic campaign, an advantage that other teams in the title race do not have.
While it’s true that some of Juventus’ rivals have struggled this season, dismissing their progress as purely a result of Serie A’s decline would be unfair. Allegri’s side may not be playing the most exciting football, but their consistency and resilience have been impressive.
The real test for Juventus will come if they win the league and return to the Champions League. Only then will we see whether they are truly back among Europe’s elite or if their current success is merely a product of a weaker domestic competition.
